Please do NOT merge unsourced duplicates into the MEDIEVAL tree

Started by Sharon Doubell on Friday, July 29, 2016
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Related Projects:

Showing 7681-7710 of 8070 posts

Hi, curators, please look and do something with profile (not medieval, but family of Dukes of Argyll is prominent and quite well documented, and can be equaled to medieval)

Mary Reay (Campbell) her sister, her mother, etc

There are not such illegitimate issue of Dukes of Argyll in available reliable sources about this quite notable and well documented family.

Mentioned profiles created by user Martin Jonathon Swann

(May be MD will say, that pretentious name of user is a mark of person with some deviations, not healthy, ADHD and similar decease?)

That user also create many other connections of his "ancestors" to WFT, but not sources mentioned.

To additions of above mentioned topic:

Hon. David Hamilton - "children" not confirmed by sources

Look to https://www.stirnet.com/genie/data/british/hh4aa/hamilton01.php:

David Hamilton (b c1543, dsp 03.1611) - 2 children (d young)

This may be confirmed by "Historical and Genealogical Memoirs of the House of Hamilton with Genealogical Memoirs of the Several Branches of the Family" by John Anderson, 1825

online available https://digital.nls.uk/histories-of-scottish-families/archive/95389...

Detached Thomas Hamilton

Detached James Hamilton

Detached Thomas Hamilton

As children of Hon. David Hamilton & Agnes Laidlaw

They all have different locations also so seem unlikely to be related to each other.

Beware “names the same” genealogy!

Louis, seigneur de Beauvau
Louis De BEAUVAU

(C) PLZ fast help,

STOP DUP /!\ Adalbert II. D'ESTE, of Lucca, Duc d'Toscana

user duplicating wrong lines under 1000
ignored and deleted duplication warnings

Livio: branch isolated for deletion.

♥️

hi (C) PLZ CUT parents of Cleph II, King of the Lombards

by 20 min ago https://www.geni.com/merge/view?revision_id=86370947690 (just easy CUT dont need UNDO)

merged on Rosamund of the Gepids now

We need to force ourselves writing something with our little fingers, if we really think we know parents of profiles from 1500 years ago... unknown to historians!

otherwise we pass for a vandal..
or worse: for digital illiterates who move like an elephant in a glassware shop ^^'

Livio Scremin — done.

Special TNX, OK the UNDO..
..but now what do we do with the newly fresh just added DUP?
*Rosamund of the Gepids, DUP
(which is not a note or even suggested MOM of the MP:)

My merge center is loaded today (Oct. 24) with tree matches in the Kirby family: (A new user manually adding her tree.)
1. https://www.geni.com/search/matches?id=6000000004533817708&src=profile&cmp=btn (Joan Kirby (Cranfield) (MP)) This line continues down to Robert Wesley Boutwell (added 2021) vs Robert Wesley Boutwell (added Oct. 2024) This is the cutpoint.
Please note: The Kirby profiles added by this user continue back to https://www.geni.com/search/matches?id=6000000066386996947&src=profile&cmp=btn (Isabella Kyrkeby (Bardsley))

(C) PLZ could you UNDO: -https://www.geni.com/merge/view?revision_id=84079065180
(so then I can whiten the fields as per 2021)

so we can see who changed the name from " 2021 no name" to "Queen of Jerusalem" on 2023 & merged ridiculously intact so far, despite direct contact with the last one that passed through there 20 days ago >.<

Hugh Russell
Hugh Russell

Has already been merged at Ralph Russell 1203

Private User - I think you have worked in this area (maybe)

These 2 are 1631 but if merged will cause issues with their pre 1600 parents

Richard Pettibone, of Hailsham in Sussex
Richard Pettibone, of 'Pettibone's Rest'

These appeared in my merge center today:
https://www.geni.com/search/matches?id=6000000210273958824&src=profile&cmp=btn (Matilda Kyriell (added today) vs 2 profiles)
One is just a father and the profile.
The other has additional children and is attached to the old profile for Sir John Steward, II
There are multiple duplicates between the trees of Matilda Kyriell and Matilda Kyriell 'This will not be an easy cut-and-isolate operation.'

I was looking around Roman profiles and found these two MPs

Rubellia Bassa
Rubellia Bassa

I assume this is on purpose to show the two theories on her parentage but her husband and a child are also duplicates and I don't know what the procedure is in that case

Hello Curators,

Please solve these issues:

https://www.geni.com/merge/compare/6000000000796891248?to=600000020...

Correct profile
Alfonso III of Portugal

DUP 2024
rei Afonso III de Portugal

Correct prolile
Madragana Ben Aloandro, Mor Afonso

DUP 2024
Madragana Bat Aloandro

Correct profile
Martim Afonso Chichorro, governador de Chaves

DUP 2024
dom Martim Afonso Sousa Chichorro

Thanks in advance.

Private User

I went ahead and merged dup Rubellia Bassa and her husband and noted the alternate mother theories in her "about." It's less confusing that way.

Private User

Sorted out Hugh Russell and Ralph Russell (who are not related to each other)

Another new user (started July 2024) posting profiles in the Medieval tree.
https://www.geni.com/search/matches?id=6000000001690621533&src=profile&cmp=btn (William Thomas Stacie, III vs William Thomas Stacie, III) The cutpoint for the Stacy portion of the tree is Elizabeth Adams (Stacy) vs Elizabeth Adams (Stacy)

However, the user has added other profiles in the Colonial tree that are incorrectly connected. Hannah Munsy (Wickingham) (new) is a duplicate of Hannah Wickingham (Adams) The stick tree, with some spouses, ends at Soldier John Munsy (new) vs Soldier John Munsy (old).

To me, everything he has added in these two trees does not add to Geni. He has added additional duplicates down to his 2nd great-grandfather. I will send him my usual message about duplicates.

Private User
Eberhard Loeben isolated for deletion.

Showing 7681-7710 of 8070 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion