Cleopatra of Jerusalem - Could Herod have had a child with Cleopatra of Egypt?

1)If the Cleopatra mother of Herod the Great, de-facto King of Judea's child Philip, Tetrarch of Judaea, is the same as the Egyptian Queen Cleopatra VII Philopator, Pharaoh of Egypt; & that child, Phillip, is the same as Ptolemy Philadelphus (whose birthdate does coincide remarkably well with Herod the Great, de-facto King of Judea's visit to Cleopatra);
then the (surmised?) birthdate of Philip, Tetrarch of Judaea should be much earlier.
If that is so, & the Cleopatras are the same, this means that the (surmised?) date for Cleopatra of Jerusalem, King Herod 7th wife ‘s -25BC marriage to Herod the Great, de-facto King of Judea is also incorrect (the Egyptian Queen having suicide 5 years’ earlier); as is the existence of Cleopatra of Jerusalem, King Herod 7th wife’s other son, Herod . (born c-23BC - for whose life there appears to be little evidence anyway.)
Without documentation to refute it, this is possible. It is also possible that both Cleopatras birthed a son for Herod, and they have become conflated.

2)Both Phillips were coincidentally educated in Rome
– The Egyptian Ptolemy Philadelphus - by Marc Anthony’s ex-wife, Octavia Minor
- & Philip, Tetrarch of Judaea, together with his half-brothers , Herod Archelaus and Herod Antipas, as a kind of honourable detention to guarantee their father, Herod the Great, de-facto King of Judea’s loyalty. [Could Octavia Minor – who only dies in -11BC have been their guardian too?]
However, Philip, Tetrarch of Judaea’s half brothers’ (born around -20BC & -23BC) are more than 10 years younger than the Egyptian Ptolemy Philadelphus (born around -36BC),so the source that lumps them together with their half brother, Philip, Tetrarch of Judaea, in describing their education, might be crucial to establishing whether he was, in fact, the older Ptolemy Philadelphus.

3) As the most important source of information on Philip, Tetrarch of Judaea is Josephus (Titus Flavius) -, & he is also the source of the info that Cleopatra "upon the whole, seemed overcome with love for him (King Herod),"(Antiquities 15.4.2); it seems unlikely that he would then miss out making the point that the two Phillips might be the same man. Unless he was hinting….:-)

It still seems, on the whole, less likely.
(But I will go and peruse his 'Antiquities' just in case) :-)

Cleopatra of Jerusalem - Could Herod have had a child with Cleopatra of Egypt?

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Related Projects:

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion