Erica,
I think I've made some headway with this. According to this, Dorothy Buckner, daughter of Richard Buckner, was born in 1673 in Rappahannock County, married Charles Smith in 1700, then, after he died in 1710, married John Roy. She was NOT the mother of Hannah Roy. Her children were Robert Smith (from the first marriage), Thomas Roy, John Roy, Jr., Reuben Roy, Mungo Roy, Richard M Roy, Mary Roy, and Elizabeth Roy.
Dorothy Buckner's husband John Roy was the son of Richard Roy and Dorothy Peyton. I think we can see where the confusion with Buckner and Peyton in Hannah Roy’s line comes from. https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=xJZNCAAAQBAJ&pg=PT419&l...
I've posted on discussion pages and/or contacted profile managers and heard nothing back.
I think we need to make Hannah Roy's parents Richard (or John Richard) Roy and Agnes McGregor. We need to cut Elizabeth smith loose from the Chew tree. She was not Larkin's wife. We need to show Dorothy Peyton as the wife of Richard Roy and Dorothy Bruckner as the wife of John Guy Roy (who was Hannah Roy's brother.
I've tried to move and merge but continually get error messages. Can you assist?
BTW, to my knowledge, Ann Johnston (Chew), Larkin Chew, Jr., Thomas Chew, and John Chew were Larkin Sr. and Hannah Roy's only surviving children.