Vincent Herbert alias Finch - Inconsistencies

Started by Sharon Doubell on Friday, May 31, 2019
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Related Projects:

Showing all 2 posts
5/31/2019 at 6:07 AM

SmartCopyConsistency Check:Henry (Herbert) Finch contains an alias in his first name.Elizabeth Herbert or Finch Ashburnham born after the death of her father Vincent Herbert alias Finch.John Herbert or Finch born after the death of his father Vincent Herbert alias Finch.Vincent Herbert or Finch born after the death of his father Vincent Herbert alias Finch.Parnell Herbert or Finch Battayle born after the death of her father Vincent Herbert alias Finch.Helen Herbert or Finch Maidstone born after the death of her father Vincent Herbert alias Finch.Deonis Herbert or Finch Waller born after the death of her father Vincent Herbert alias Finch.NN Herbert or Finch Colehand born after the death of her father Vincent Herbert alias Finch.Margaret Herbert or Finch Allard born after the death of her father Vincent Herbert alias Finch.Isabel Herbert or Finch Allard born after the death of her father Vincent Herbert alias Finch.

5/31/2019 at 12:15 PM

Was reading the About info on Vincent. It states that his family descends from Mathew fitz Herbert, Magna Carta witness, & his son, Mathew. But, Mathew, the elder, only had a son named Herbert fitz Mathew (no issue).

So was "jogging" around the Internet trying to reconcile this line. There is a Sir Piers fitz Herbert, Baron & Sheriff of Yorkshire, who was a Magna Carta witness. (Ca 1163, Powis, Wales - June 1, 1235, Berkshire, Eng). He m. 3 times, but he didn't have a son named Matthew. He did, however, have a brother Matthew (ca 1166-1231), ...this is the same Matthew mentioned above, both sons of Herbert fitz Herbert & Lucy fitz Miles.

The question then is the Peter fitz Herbert, ancestor of Vincent, the same as Sir Piers fitz Herbert? And, if so, then Vincent's line shouldbe corrected, which might help with the dates.

The profile for Peter fitz Herbert (b. Est. betw. 1198-1258) shows that he m. Alice fitz Roger. But, the profile for Sir Piers shows that his 1st wife was Alice fitz Robert, daughter of Robert fitz Roger. Are these 2 women the same?

Peter FitzHerbert

Sir Piers FitzHerbert, Lord of Brecknock & Sheriff of Yorkshire

(I have 4 lines here, so hope that it can be resolved)

Showing all 2 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion