These siblings have multiple parents on Geni
* 1826 Robert Horton
* 1828 Elizabeth Mitchell
* 1830 Eliza Talbot
* 1834 Harriet Hartley
* 1839 John Horton
* 1843 Sarah Rugless
* 1844 James Horton
* 1847 Sylvester Horton
* 1847 Celesta Sarah Overill
* 1850 Angelina Horton, infant
Parents set 1
* father - James David Horton (1808-1893) - son of David (Halton) Horton [Convict "William and Ann" 1791] (1772-1842) and Elizabeth Minnie (Smith - Madden) Horton [Convict "Speedy" 1800] (1779-1831)
* mother - Sarah (Burnside) Horton, Free Settler "Ann" 1810 (1809-1900) - daughter of Ambrose Thomas Burnside, Marine "Ann" 1810 (1779-1827) and Sarah Agnes (Boyd) Burnside, Free Settler "Ann" 1810 (1786-1840)
Parents set 2
* father David Horton (1804-1885) - son of David (Halton) Horton [Convict "William and Ann" 1791] (1772-1842) and Elizabeth Minnie (Smith - Madden) Horton [Convict "Speedy" 1800] (1779-1831)
* mother Sarah Horton (1807-1900) - daughter of John (Hannabus) Hannibus, Convict "Ganges" 1797 (1770-1847) and Margaret (Edwards) Hannibus, Convict "Britannia" 1798 (1782-1846)
Can anyone provide any information to determine where they belong.
NSW Birth Records
* 875/1826 V1826875 20 Robert HORTON, father James, mother Sarah BURNSIDE
* 1202/1839 V18391202 25A John HORTON, father James, mother Sarah
* 1482/1844 V18441482 28 James HORTON, father James, mother Sarah
* 1337/1847 V18471337 32A Sylvester HORTON, father James, mother Sarah
* 51/1850 V185051 35 Angelina HORTON, father James, mother Sarah
NSW Marriage Records
* 260/1836 V1836260 20 James HORTON to Sarah BURNSIDE
NSW Death Records
* 6353/1862 Angelina HORTON, father James, mother Sarah - Windsor
Australian Baptism Record - Robert HORTON, born 31/5/1826, baptised 22/11/1836 Pitt Town, father James HORTON, mother Sarah BURNSIDE
Australian Baptism Record - Elizabeth HORTON, born 12/9/1828, baptised 22/11/1836 Pitt Town, father James HORTON, mother Sarah BURNSIDE
Australian Marriage Record - Robert MITCHELL married Elizabeth HORTON on 8/12/1846 Pitt Town
Australian Baptism Record - Eliza HORTON, born 12/2/1830, baptised 22/11/1836 Pitt Town, father James HORTON, mother Sarah BURNSIDE
Australian Baptism Record - John HORTON, born 7/4/1839, baptised 28/2/1841 Wilberforce and Pitt Town, father James HORTON, mother Sarah
https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/166797555
Sydney Mail - Saturday 5 October 1867 Page 10
MARRIAGE
OVERILL—HORTON—September 6th, by the Rev. Dr. Bailey
of the Free Church of England, Mr. George OVERILL, of Old
South Head Road, Paddington, to Celesta, daughter of the late
Mr. James HORTON, of 33, East-street.
This Ann has no dates but she is probably the sister of Sarah BURNSIDE
* https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Burnside-285
Ann BURNSIDE 1819-1882
married George MARTIN
married JAMES LEWIS
* https://gw.geneanet.org/bmuckleston?lang=en&iz=115&p=anne&a...