Jane Joan Pugh (Milner) - Dates?

Looks like a spurious pedigree.

===Research notes

https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Pew-1

Apparently a "consultant" once concocted an unsourced line for a client which made the Pugh sisters be the daughters of a Jane Milner, allegedly daughter of Elizabeth Rolfe, the lost daughter of John Rolfe (last heard of in her father's will in 1622).

Attempts to reconcile this with the sources have led to the evolution of a version which divides Henry Pugh into two people, father and son. This is now in general circulation.

But note that the Henry Pugh who wrote his will in 1709 was an old man, as he had a grown-up grandson who he made executor.

Note also that Henry's daughters get a shilling each, so it's unlikely there was a living son not mentioned at all.

However, the following records do suggest there was a younger Henry Pew, possibly a nephew.

From http://heathcock.org/genealogy/ps09/ps09_477.html

The only reference to Elizabeth Rolfe growing to adulthood and becoming the wife of John Milner is in a chart prepared by Coleman Price, 1940, on file at the Virginia State Library. There is no documentation to confirm this family.

In the article "Progenitors and Kinfolk of Abraham Childers, III" in the Virginia Genealogist, Vol 34, page 11, there is a notation.....'Elizabeth Rolfe, whose parents were John Rolfe and his third wife Jane Pierce. This cannot be proved owing to the loss of the early Henrico County, Virginia records.'

So we just do not really know if this is the right person or not. It is based on the Family Group Sheet prepared as stated above.

Nevertheless, the hypothetical and perhaps apocryphal story that Elizabeth Pierce Rolfe lived long enough to marry John Milner and have a daughter named Jane in 1635 has gained traction and is found in numerous places

'''Caution''': Apparently a "consultant" once concocted an unsourced line for a client which made the Pugh / Pew sisters be the daughters of a Jane Milner, allegedly daughter of Elizabeth Rolfe, the lost daughter of John Rolfe (last heard of in her father's will in 1622). As of November 2020, we see Anne and Jane Pew as the two known children of Henry Pew of Henrico (died 1711) and his wife Jane.

Henry Pew, of Henrico & Jane Pew parents of Ann Adkins & Jane Ligon

Birth: 1618 Virginia, USA Death: 1685 Virginia, USA

John Milner was likely born between 1618 to 1620. Some historians believe him to be the husband of Elizabeth Pierce Rolfe (b:1620-d:1635), who was daughter of John Rolfe - prominent Virginia Company and Jamestown figure in American history - and his third wife, Jane Pierce.

The problem is that Elizabeth died at age 15 and a marriage record has not been found. If they did marry, John likely outlived Elizabeth, but records of his birth or death dates have not been proven by historical documentation.

—-
Tagging John Milner, Sr. & Elizabeth Milner