Query on Annie Butler CHISHOLM

https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:XTHJ-796

Name Anne Butler Chisholm
Sex Female
Christening Date 26 Aug 1846
Christening Place New South Wales, Australia
Christening Place (Original) St Andrews Sydney N.S.W. Ausl
Birth Date 8 May 1846
Birthplace New South Wales, Australia
Father's Name George Chisholm
Father's Sex Male
Mother's Name Anne Butler Bourne
Mother's Sex Female

I have found trees with different Anne Butler CHISHOLM

• died 1900 - married Frederick William RUTTER
• died 1919 - married William Charles FULTON

NSW Marriage Record
Registration number
1543/1873
Groom's Family Name
RUTTER
Groom's Given Name(s)
FREDERICK WILLIAM
Bride's Family Name(s)
CHISHOLME
Bride's Given Name(s)
ANNIE BUTTER
District
ST GEORGE

NSW Marriage Record
Registration number
2589/1860
Groom's Family Name
FULTON
Groom's Given Name(s)
WILLIAM CHARLES
Bride's Family Name(s)
CHISHOLM
Bride's Given Name(s)
ANNIE BUTLER
District
SOFALA

NSW Death Record
RUTTER ANNIE B
Registration number
2703/1900
Father's Given Name(s)
GEORGE
Mother's Given Name(s)
ANN B
District
NEWTOWN

NSW Birth Record
CHISHOLM ANNE
Registration number
3629/1840 V18403629 45B
Father's Given name(s)
WILLIAM
Mother's Given name(s)
CHRISTIANA
District

NSW Birth Record
CHISHOLM ANNE B
Registration number
5968/1846 V18465968 45C
Father's Given name(s)
GEORGE
Mother's Given name(s)
ANNE B
District

NSW Death Record
FULTON ANNIE B
Registration number
14670/1921
Father's Given Name(s)
JOHN
Mother's Given Name(s)
79 YRS PENRITH
District
PENRITH

Annie - wife of William FULTON died 23/9/1920

https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/86191136?searchTerm=anni...
Nepean Times - Sat 4 October 1919 - Page 2

Annie Butler Fulton died last week - relict of William Charles FULTON died aged 79
daughter of the late Mr and Mrs CHISHOLM
born 1 September 1840
married 1860 to William Charles FULTON - brother of James FULTON
Surviving siblings - William CHISHOLM, John CHISHOLM, Mrs SHOOBERT

https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/86191808?searchTerm=anni...
Deaths.
FULTON. — 24th September, 1919, at Glen
coe, Penrith, Annie Butler relict of the
late William Charles Fulton, sen.,
aged 79 years.

Mary C CHISHOLM married Henry SHOOBERT in 1872

Registration number
370/1872
Groom's Family Name
SHOOBERT
Groom's Given Name(s)
HENRY
Bride's Family Name(s)
CHISHOLM
Bride's Given Name(s)
MARY C
District
SYDNEY

Mary C SHOOBERT died in 1931 - daughter of William and Christina

SHOOBERT MARY C
Registration number
6746/1931
Father's Given Name(s)
WILLIAM
Mother's Given Name(s)
CHRISTINA
District
MOSMAN

She was born in 1846
CHISHOLM MARY C
Registration number
6045/1846 V18466045 45C
Father's Given name(s)
WILLIAM
Mother's Given name(s)
CHRISTIANA
District

RESOLVED

There are 2 Annie Butler CHISHOLM's

Annie Butler Rutter 1846-1900

• father George Chisholm 1806-1873
• mother Anne B Chisholm 1819-1850
• married Frederick William Rutter

Annie Butler Fulton 1840-1919

• father William W Chisholm 1812-1867
• mother Christiana Chisholm 1811-1900
• married William Charles Fulton

With such an unusual name it is possible that they were cousins (fathers were brothers) but more research needs to be done to prove this.