Ardevaste 'the Greek' Balthes, Prince of the Visigoths - Parents

Started by Debbie Gambrell on Wednesday, January 11, 2023
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Related Projects:

Showing 1-30 of 32 posts

Supposedly, these are my ancestors, so I was tracing them on Medlands, where it states that the parents of this Ardebast (ARDABASTO on Medlands) are unknown, mentioning that the parentage connected here on Geni as being unproven:

ARDABASTO, son of --- . The Chronicle of Alfonso III records that "Ardabastus came from Greece after being expelled from his country by the emperor…arrived in Spain" and was "received…magnificently" by King Chindasvinto who gave him his niece in marriage[356]. His parentage is unknown, although this passage suggests that he must have been a person of importance in Byzantium. Salazar y Castro, in his genealogical table of the Visigothic kings, shows "Atanagildo" as the son of Hermenegildo, as well as his marriage to "Flavia Juliana hija de Pedro Augusto, hermano del Emperador Mauricio", and their sons "Paulo" and "Ardavasto", as well as the latter´s marriage to "prima, hija o hermana del Rey Cindasuindo"[357] (see above). The primary sources on which these statements are based are not specified. The table includes numerous errors and the information should therefore be viewed with caution. The name "Ardabasto" suggests a connection with Armenia, "Artavazd" being one of the names used frequently in the Mamikonian family of Armenia, holders of the hereditary position "sparapet" [supreme general] between the 5th and 8th centuries[358]. There could also be a connection with Artabasdos (-before 772), strategos of the theme of Armenia, who in 717 married Anna, daughter of Emperor Leon III "the Isaurian".

If the connections are unproven, then the entre lineage beyond the connected parents are speculative and I can't truly count them as my ancestors. So is there any additional information to support the connections?

Thanks in advance for any assistance.

Debbie Gambrell - can you add notes to the profile abouts?

I meant to include the Medlands link which is where the above notes came from:

http://fmg.ac/Projects/MedLands/VANDALS,%20SUEVI,%20VISIGOTHS.htm#E...

This profile already has all those notes and more:

Ardebasto

and he's the one showing as my direct ancestor via the line of his son ERVIGIO also listed on the Medlands link.

The first note in his About section already states:

Ardabasto. According to Salazar y Castro, he was the son of a supposed son of Hermenegildo the Visigoth who married a relative (Flavia Juliana) of Emperor Mauricius. The connection is speculative.

To be sure.

Are you saying the two profiles are the same

https://www.geni.com/merge/compare/6000000189160702845

Ardebasto & Ardebasto

And with no parents?

At this point I've been working on other things and have lost track. Here's all I know at this point:

Ardebasto

isn't showing as my direct ancestor but has the mother Flavia Juliana that Medlands lists for this one who is:

Ardebasto

even though his Geni profile doesn't have parents connected. The one who is the father of '

Ervigio, King of the Visigoths

and Medlands doesn't have a name for Ervigio's mother, so I don't know what the source for the mother Goda here on Geni is.

Everything seems to be accurate up to ERVIGIO and that's where what's on Geni and what's on Medlands begin to differ.

is definitely the one on Medlands. Whether the two men are the same or not, I don't know. I don't know if Ardevaste and Ardabasto are variants of the same name or not, but both are listed as 'the Greek'.

I don't know these lines and don't work on ancient connections enough to know anything more than what Medlands shows that I've already shared. That's why I was hoping for help sorting it all out.

Isn't there a group who specifically work on ancient lines like these?

“Group” Jason Scott Wills you are summoned.

There have been recent changes in this area.

Disconnecting the parental relationship to Atanagildo and Flavia Juliana

Re-curating from Victar.

Thank you for spotting.

Disconnecting Galswintha, queen consort of Neustria as his wife.

GALSWINTHA (-murdered [567]). Gregory of Tours records the marriage of King Chilperic and Galswintha, older daughter of King Atanagildo, after the marriage of King Sigebert to her younger sister, specifying that she converted from Arianism to Catholicism and came to France with a large dowry, but never stopped complaining about the insults she had to endure to the king who eventually had her garrotted by one of his servants[182]. Herimannus names "Geisluindam, sororem Brunæ [filiam Athanagildi regis Gothorum]" as wife of "Hilpericus frater Sigibertus rex", recording that she was strangled by her husband's concubine "Fridegundis"[183]. m (564) as his second wife, CHILPERIC I King of the Franks, son of CLOTAIRE I [Chlothachar] King of the Franks & his fourth wife Arnegundis (before 535-murdered Chelles [27 Sep/9 Oct] 584, bur Paris, Saint-Germain-des-Prés).

https://fmg.ac/Projects/MedLands/VANDALS,%20SUEVI,%20VISIGOTHS.htm#...

Thank you, Sharon Doubell

ARDABASTO
s/o NN
x ([642]) --- of the Visigoths, niece of CHINDASVINTO King of the Visigoths

  • ERVIGIO ([643]-Toledo 15 Nov 687)

cf

My pleasure. So great when people help us spotting errors.

Ardevaste 'the Greek' Balthes, Prince of the Visigoths is your 41st great grandfather.
Atanagildo II, rey de los visigodos is your first cousin 43 times removed.
Flavia Juliana is your 10th cousin 42 times removed.
Ervigio, rey de los visigodos is your 40th great grandfather.
Glasvinta Balthes is your 41st great grandmother.

Was Atanagildo even a king or have the children attached? I can’t even find a Wikipedia article on hm.

King Leovigildo & his first wife had two children:

1. HERMENEGILDO “the Holy” ([550/55]-murdered Tarragona 13 Apr 586). … The Iohannis Abbatis Biclarensis Chronica records that Hermenegildo was sent into exile in 584 and in 585 was killed "in urbe Tarraconensi" by "Sisberto"[224]. He was canonised in 1586.

m (579) INGUNDIS [Ingonde] of the Franks, daughter of SIGEBERT I King of the Franks & his wife Brunechildis of the Visigoths ([567/68]-in Africa Autumn 586). ... She fled to Africa with her son after her husband was killed, seeking refuge with the Eastern Emperor[229].

Hermenegildo and his wife had one child:

  • a) son . Paulus Diaconus records that, after Ingundis was captured following her husband's death, "filius eius" was handed over to Emperor Mauricius and taken to Constantinople[230]. same person as…? ATANAGILDO. Salazar y Castro, in his genealogical table of the Visigothic kings, shows "Atanagildo" as the son of Hermenegildo, as well as his marriage to "Flavia Juliana hija de Pedro Augusto, hermano del Emperador Mauricio", and their sons "Paulo" and "Ardavasto", as well as the latter´s marriage to "prima, hija o hermana del Rey Cindasuindo"[231] (see below). The primary sources on which these statements are based are not specified. The table includes numerous errors and the information should therefore be viewed with caution.

And more:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ingund_(wife_of_Hermenegild)

17th-century Spanish genealogist Luis Bartolomé de Salazar y Castro gave Ardabast's father as Athanagild, the son of Saint Hermenegild and Ingund, and his mother as Flavia Juliana, a daughter of Peter Augustus and niece of the Emperor Maurice.[20] This imperial connection is disputed by Christian Settipani, who says that the only source for Athanagild's marriage to Flavia Julia is José Pellicer, who he claims to be a forger.[21]

There is no Atangildo ll as king of the Visigoths.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visigothic_Kingdom

https://www.cervantesvirtual.com/bib/historia/monarquia/visigodos.s...

Unless anyone can say differently, I will remove the title and family from Atanagildo

Husband of Flavia Juliana
Father of Ofilón, I; Paulo Balthes and Estéban Balthes

Thanks for all that research work, Erica.

I have not yet delved into the details of this branch of my family, but it seems that the approach to simply pull the plug on an established relationship without any discussion or chance for people who mapped out the relationships to present their initial reasoning and evidence is a recipe for conflict.

Hi Private User

You may enjoy looking at this project we’re working on.

Kings of the Visigoths

https://www.geni.com/projects/Kings-of-the-Visigoths/4491311

Private User This Discussion is the managers' chance to provide the primary sources. That's why those profiles are deliberately linked into the Discussion as we disconnect. It automatically alerts the managers, and provides reference to the profile so we can easily reconnect if we find proof of validity.
In more than 95% of cases, managers never reply, and there is so much to do on Geni that the initial request is lost until we come across it again - often years later - still not sorted out, unless we've done it simultaneous to the alert.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visigothic_Kingdom#Family_tree

? ?
Gada Ardabasto

Erwig
King of the
Visigoths
aft.642–680-687

Private User - see notes at

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erwig

According to the 9th-century Chronicle of Alfonso III, Erwig was the son of Ardabast, who had journeyed from the Byzantine Empire to Hispania during the time of Chindasuinth, and married Chindasuinth's niece Goda.[3] Ardabast (or Artavasdos), was probably an Armenian or Persian Christian exile in Constantinople or in Byzantine Africa. In Hispania he was made a count.[4]
Seventeenth-century Spanish genealogist Luis Bartolomé de Salazar y Castro gave Ardabast's father as Athanagild, the son of Saint Hermenegild and Ingund, and his mother as Flavia Juliana, a daughter of Peter Augustus and niece of the Emperor Maurice.[5] This imperial connection is disputed by Christian Settipani, who says that the only source for Athanagild's marriage to Flavia Julia is José Pellicer, who he claims to be a forger.[6]

So possible adjustments to Ardebasto

  • he wasn’t a prince, was he? A count?
  • he wasn’t at a Balti dynasty member, was he? So why the surname Balthes?
  • I don’t see the second child for him & “Goda” at Medlands??? Added “Goda” & Gada to AKA field for NN, of the Visigoths

I've updated the name. Usually I try to do the minimal amount on profiles I don't manage, presuming the managers have come to a consensus conclusion using facts. I agree that I don't see any supporting that name here. Thank you.

There seems to be a lag in updating Display Name right now.

Re:

I added N.N. as parent of NN, of the Visigoths & sibling of Chindasvinto, rey de los visigodos

Great idea. I've locked the relationships

Thank you for that link. The issues at hand are to a large extent a problem of the GENi policy for how they handle such questions about existing master profiles. It appears that they make no effort to contact the people who host a certain profile but act god-like and shut it down without warning. It is a trainwreck policy which might be easy to do upfront but has tons of fallout.

Showing 1-30 of 32 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion