Sigismund Simon Brandstetter - Unsourced child of Prince Johann Georg von Hohenzollern

Started by Private User on yesterday
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Showing all 9 posts

What is this profile, where are the sources for this and who has connected it back as child of Johann Georg von Hohenzollern? Based on what?
This familysite doesn't mrntion anything about this familyline being descended from the Hohen,ollern, at least. And I can imagine thry have researched this line before putting them on a site.

https://www.anamericanfamilyhistory.com/Branstiter%20Family/Branste...

This is full of bull too: Princess Maria Katharina Brandstetter

All merged into the line of:

Prince Johann Georg von Hohenzollern

Besides this Sigismund has already been once disconnected from this line so someone has connected him recently back into it and made his farmer mother a princess and wife of Johann Georg von Hohenzollern... Ridiculous.

Livio Scremin I saw you have done some work on these profiles, do you agree that this Sigismund has nothing to do with the Hohenzollern that he has been connected to as thrir son? Nor has his mother anything to do with the Hohenzollern either...nor was she a princess, I am confident.

LOL HI @Maria,
hi you did well to tag me, because I passed by here in October 2023 and I don't seem to administer anything in the area.. but I'm answering you quickly while I also check.

Well as you can see I had left the JPG of warning eye provable "DIY node".. "source PLZ" ..
-https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Brandstetter-13 (c.1630-...)
Son of [father unknown] and [mother unknown] [siblings unknown]

------
Now I see that in August then in effect USER: Rachal Bhnay Davis added: as source
-https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/2Z3Q-SGY

the problem is that not everyone knows that this type of site is mainly for looking for contemporary relatives... as you go up in the centuries it loses all reliability... until you see real fantasies in the early Middle Ages. Here, I really wouldn't know how to make myself useful.

------

maybe now while I post, I'll also take a look at the incomplete merge on: Simon Doll

OMG disaster of unfinished fresh merges &/or UNDO by PRO user after last 2021 (C) work around here >.<
also on MP Hans Peter Dull

Really out of my space, time, & interest, but I hope these TAGS wake up the right people :D
Good luck!

FFS!!!!! Why does it seem to be so hard for some to understand this is a one world tree and that fake genealogy should be kept out of it. Deleted my last comment because of severe typos..am on phone.

We should have somekind of policy, likie wikitree(even if there are errors too) where in order to tougch some profiles pre 1800's or pre1700' and pre 1500's one should complete somekind of a test. Adding stuff from sites like Familysearch tto profiles pre 1600's at least, should be banned! We have real source literature for that as is known by real genealogists all over the world. I am sure we will start to find a huge mess of DUP'S...whole branches if not entire trees very soon. I think I have bumped into some but was on a different mission then so I didn't investigate properly.

Showing all 9 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion