William Pinnell, Jr. - Who is William Pinnell (d 1774)?

Is it possible though that these 3 sons who ended up in South Carolina actually from Sarah Bagly / Bayley and William Pannell / Pinnell?

History of the Pinnell-Royal Families" by Royall E Pinnell (~1968) < image > - can we get to the next pages? They list 9 children and not the 6 listed at https://colonial-settlers-md-va.us/getperson.php?personID=I28485&tr... (which includes the will and probate).

Or - was it formerly listed and no longer valid?

This site https://sites.rootsweb.com/~pinnell/html/fam00425.htm seems close -- or was it a different Pinnell?

Made a new profile: William Pinnell, of Catawba

Not the same as William Pannell, of St. Mary's Parish

Source: "History of the Pinnell-Royal Families" by Royall E Pinnell (~1968), page viewer 19 of 287. < FamilySearch >; book link < FamilySearch >

---

References

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catawba,_South_Carolina Catawba (cuh-TAW-buh) is an unincorporated community in York County, South Carolina, United States, southeast of the city of Rock Hill.

   ---

   
   

Please feel free to request management if interested.

Does he have the brothers Jonathan Pinnell & Lewis Pinnell

How do you want to handle the sourcing from

1. This man? https://sites.rootsweb.com/~pinnell/html/fam00425.htm (Only Peter Pinnell b. 1755 matches)
2. "History of the Pinnell-Royal Families" by Royall E Pinnell (~1968), page viewer 19 of 287. < FamilySearch >; book link < FamilySearch >

Tagging Faustine Darsey on hiatus to assist further on the Peter Pinnell, Sr. family.

re: Your William Pannill and his wife were born and died in Virginia!

No. That's the William Pannill I detached him from.

The source reference is this:

Source: "History of the Pinnell-Royal Families" by Royall E Pinnell (~1968), page viewer 19 of 287. < FamilySearch >; book link < FamilySearch >

A discussion of Peter Pinnell is here:

https://www.geni.com/documents/view?doc_id=6000000209602377862

The book source has photocopies of documents attached.

Page 37 of 287

https://www.familysearch.org/library/books/viewer/100447/?offset=0#...

Private User

You're confusing the William Pannell / Pannill I detached Peter Pinnell from with the brand new, source based William Pinnell of Catawba. They are not meant to be the same person.

You can argue with the source and detach if you like, but they are not a confusion on my part.

Not saying it didn't happen, but we need proof.

That's all up to you. I've done my part.

But didn't you link as Peter's father a William who moved to NC in 1698?

No, I did not. I detached the William described at https://colonial-settlers-md-va.us/getperson.php?personID=I28485&tr... from Peter, and started a new William Pinnell, who supposedly moved down the Catawba.

Clearly he is not Culpeper William Pannell. Nor do I understand why William Parnell of South Carolina was named a Jr. by the source.

The children of William Pannell, of St. Mary's Parish are listed in his profile. No South Carolina people.

See the first message and the profile “abouts.”

https://www.genealogy.com/ftm/p/i/n/Donald-M-Pinnell/GENE1-0001.html

Notes for JONATHAN PINNELL:

Jonathan often used the surname PENNELL, or PINNION.The reason for this is unknown, although his brothers Lewis and Peter, and Jonathan's son Richard also frequently used variations of the surname.This has made it more difficult to identify Jonathan's parents.

And that’s as much as I know.

https://www.genealogy.com/ftm/p/i/n/Donald-M-Pinnell/index.html

The earliest records we have found of my ggg grandfather, Jonathan PINNELL and his wife, Jemima (surname unknown),are from Union County, SC, about 1783.Census records for 1800 and later indicate that he was born about 1755-1758.In 1800, Jonathan's land was adjacent to or near those of Peter and Burrel PINNEL and Lewis PENNIL.We believe these four were brothers or otherwise closely related.Census, Deed and Court records show that Jonathan and his family owned property in Union, Craven, Spartanburg and Greenville Counties, SC by 1800.For reasons unknown, over the years, members of the family often used the surnames PINION, PINNION, or PENYON, as well asseveral variations in thespelling of PINNELL.We have many documents to support this fact, including several which use different names for the same person within a single document.By 1810, Peter and his wife, Ann Yarbrough (Nancy Yarber) had emigrated to Kentucky and thence to Misssouri.By 1820, Jonathan and his second wife, Rebecca GARRARD, were living in Hall County, GA, where Jonathan died in late 1831.Jonathan's youngest son, Richard, in 1850, is resident in DeKalb County, GA, using the name PENION.I would be most interested in any information relating to the ancestry of Jonathan and his line, and I will gladly share the information I have.There is a widely accepted school of thought that Peter was the son of William and Sarah (BAGLY) PANNELL, and any authoritative evidence supportingthis contention would be greatly appreciated. I am currently researching the surnames PINNELL (in all it's variations), GARRARD, STONE, WILBOURN, EVINES, MCCRARY, BONE and FRANKLIN.My wife's family lines include the surnames AYE, DELONG, ROHMAN, and FOSTER in Missouri, Illinois, Indiana and Iowa.
The Pinnell/Pinion Family Home Page
Updated August 8, 2012